"Requiem for the Meiji Patriots" climaxes with a life or death duel between two men who admire and respect each other.
They don't duel over hatred, but over a difference in philosophy. Shigure still kills to avenge the memory of his loved
ones; while Kenshin has sworn to atone for his victims by never killing again for any cause, including peace.
Shigure realizes, to his shame, that Kenshin's way is nobler; "Requiem" has two heroes, or none. Thus, although they
wind up settling their differences with swords, Kenshin and Shigure's conflict represents not the struggle of good vs.
evil, but the struggle of one character with blood on his hands to help a kindred spirit come to grips with the blood on
his own hands.
In fact, although they fought on opposite sides in the Bakumatsu (Japanese civil War), and fight against each other
again now, "Requiem" director Hatsuki Tsuji avoids portraying Kenshin or Shigure as the bad guy. Instead two supporting
characters fill that role. Shigure's aide Kajiki and Baron Tomono of the Japanese army collaborate with each other from
the start. Tomono steals military equipment to arm Kajiki and Shigure, and Kajiki informs on Shigure's plans so that
Tomono can easily thwart the main attack. By each betraying their compatriots they hope to disgrace Tomono's superiors
and maneuver Tomono into a position of real power, from which he, of course, will promote Kajiki to a high post. Each
side of the armed conflict, then, has one noble character and one treacherous villain.
Indeed, although set against the backdrop of the most turbulent times and epochal changes in Japanese history,
"Requiem" doesn't comment on history much at all. It is a story about the process of personal atonement and redemption.
As such it makes a thoroughly appropriate bookend to the "Samurai X" OAV series that tells the story of the beginning of
Kenshin's saga, depicting his descent into darkness and torment.
Mysteriously, although it's irrelevant to viewers of only "Samurai X" the motion picture, Kenshin seems to have aged
backwards between the OAV, the TV series, and this film. He's drawn as being more slightly built, with brighter hair and
a larger scar than ever before. His voice has also become squeakier- although in the English language dub the childishness
of his voice is much less exaggerated. The whole English language cast, in fact, gives the young characters slightly more
mature voices, and plays the dramatic scenes with more restraint and gravitas.
In the "Samurai X" OAV series, Kenshin falls in love with, and loses, a woman whose fiancée he had killed months ago.
Now at the end of "Samurai X" the motion picture, Shigure, whom Kenshin has helped to save, winds up in the arms of another
woman whose brother Kenshin killed years ago. Kenshin ends up alone and bloodied as usual, but if his kindred spirit Shigure
can be saved and wind up with Toki, perhaps there's hope for Kenshin yet.