akadot News Articles Columns Reviews Fun Features Forums Retail
by Dan Borses  
3x3 Eyes box
robotech4-01
robotech4-02
review ratings information
synopsis
Episode 19: Bursting Point

Faced with growing civilian discontent and an intransigent admiralty, Captain Gloval disobeys orders in order to publicize the plight of the 56,000 civilians trapped aboard the SDF-1, a risk that pays off when the North American Ontario Quadrant agrees to the deportation of the civilian population to its territory. Unfortunately, Khyron launches another massive assault on the ship, forcing Gloval to use the new Omni-directional Barrier system to protect the battle fortress. The prolonged attack strains the new barrier system, causing a massive overload. A blast levels part of Ontario in a twenty-five mile radius, destroying a city and trapping Ben Dixon in the explosion. Faced with massive casualties on the ground, Ontario rescinds its offer and orders the battle fortress to leave its airspace. In the meantime, the ace Zentradi pilot Myria, seeking revenge for her humiliation at the hands of Max Sterling, arrives on the ship as another micronized spy.

Episode 20: Paradise Lost

Disgusted with Azonia's lack of success in capturing the battle fortress, Supreme Commander Dolza returns Breetai to command of the operation and puts nearly a million warships at his disposal. Shortly thereafter, Rico, Bron and Konda, the spies placed aboard the SDF-1 to study Micronian culture, report the strange living habits of Macross' civilians to their leader. Their enthusiasm for Micronian culture proves infectious, as many of the Zentradi soldiers flock around the returned spies to learn of Micronian culture. Back aboard the SDF-1, Gloval announces that the SDF-1 has received orders to take the battle fortress back into space with the civilians to protect the Earth-bound population.

Episode 21: A New Dawn

The opening of Minmei's new movie lifts the spirits of those aboard the SDF-1. Though flush with success, Minmei arranges to reserve Rick a seat in the front row. Rick, unfortunately, does not get the message. Instead, he braves the crowd, leaving Minmei to see the empty seat up front. One scene in the movie requires Minmei to kiss her co-star, Kyle. The sight fills Rick with jealousy, compelling him to leave the theater. Outside, he runs into Lisa who is still haunted by the similarities between Kyle and her late fiancé, Karl. A sudden modular transformation traps Rick and Lisa together during a battle emergency, leaving the two to realize that they might be better off together.

Episode 22: Battle Hymn

Mistaking an intercepted transmission of Minmei and Kyle's movie for a battle record, Dolza becomes convinced that Micronians possess formidable fighting skills, leading him to redouble his efforts to capture the ship. In response, Breetai concocts a plan that will allow the Zentradi to place battle pods into the ship through the Daedalus arm so that the SDF-1 can be captured from within. Meanwhile, a group of renegade Zentradi led by Rico, Konda and Bron reduce themselves to Micronian size and plan to defect to the Robotech vessel.

Episode 23: Reckless

In the midst of the attack on the Battle Fortress, many of the Zentradi soldiers switch sides, causing the assault to fail. Rico, Bron and Konda are the first to turn themselves over to the Robotech Defense Fortress, and are granted asylum by Captain Gloval. In the light of new scientific evidence indicating that humans and Zentradi have virtually identical cell structures, Lisa Hayes requests permission to travel to Earth to protect the right of the defectors and persuade the United Earth Government to give the Zentradi the option of living as Micronians instead of waging war.

Episode 24: Showdown

Before leaving the SDF-1, Lisa contacts Rick Hunter by telephone to inform him of her plans. When Khyron's forces attack her ship, Rick comes to her aid and delivers her safely to Earth, conveying his deep-found respect for her using the signal lights on his Veritech. Rick returns to the ship to watch a press conference in which Kyle spontaneously announces his intention to marry Minmei. Though Minmei is shocked by the idea, Rick takes the development as proof that his own relationship with Minmei is dead in the water.

Noticing that Rick seems depressed, Max takes him to a local arcade to cheer him up. Once there, Max engages the micronized-Zentradi spy Myria in a video game, decisively beating her. Myria storms out of the arcade, frustrated with her inability to defeated the Micronian ace, but not before agreeing to meet him in the park the following day.

review
As the saga continues to unfold, the tension of the war continues to build to new and exciting levels, setting the stage for some of the most exciting battle scenes of the entire series. Unfortunately, the episodes in the fourth disc show many signs of rushed translation work and sloppy storytelling, most noticeable in scenes involving Minmei's performances and in ambiguities involving the romantic relationship between Rick Hunter and Lisa Hayes.

The most prominent evidence of excess haste is the state of Minmei's performances. As portrayed in "Robotech," Minmei fails to demonstrate a believable amount of talent to captivate the civilians of the SDF-1. Keeping her from fulfilling this role is the fact that the producers have given her a paltry two songs to perform, neither one of which is versatile enough to justify its inclusion in such a wide variety of situations. Her first song, "Stage Fright," is an egocentric recount of Minmei's feelings about becoming a star, and her second, "To Be in Love," butchers the already trite love-song genre. The constant use of these two tunes throughout several shows adds the danger of over-exposure to the already tedious mix of poor songs and vital plot points. Macek's failure to make Minmei's talent more believable is even more appalling when her songs are juxtaposed with Ulpio Minucci's dynamic score. Clearly, the producers at Harmony Gold had access to musical talent, but chose not to expend such resources to make Minmei's meteoric success more plausible.

The heretofore steady development of Rick and Lisa's relationship hits a few snags in the fourth set of episodes as well, driving Rick closer to Lisa one moment, and having him proclaim he fights only for Minmei the next. In addition, the writers flub Lisa's side, having Lisa come to the realization that her attraction for Lynn Kyle stems from his physical resemblance to Karl Riber one moment, then having her swoon at the sight of him the next. The writers attempt to patch the plot-hole by having Lisa state her sympathy to Kyle's pacifistic aims, but the attempt comes of clumsily considering that Kyle is not truly pacifist; he merely rants about the military to buttress his dwindling sense of self-worth. The reasons for this kind of imprecise character-mapping seems clear considering that "Robotech's" plot had to match the animation available (for example, if Rick were not terrified for Minmei's safety during the Zentradi penetration of the ship, the writers would have been unable to focus on Kyle's growing attraction to his cousin) but the net effect of such sloppy storytelling is vitiating the character drama at the heart of "Robotech's" story.

Fortunately, some of the excitement of the source material shines through the editing flaws, ensuring that the war story remains compelling. The defection of the Zentradi spies finally reveals the enemy's weakness to the crew of the SDF-1: the Zentradi have known nothing but war, and would like to experience the happiness and joy that comes with Micronian lifestyle. Also, the battle scenes aboard the SDF-1 are some of the most intense in the series, as the tight quarters of the ship provide a unique spin on urban mecha-combat. The ubiquitous fires seem much more threatening in tight confines. The sight of an enraged Khyron hunting down and executing deserters reinforces his villainy, painting him as a vainglorious hothead who fails to see the defections coming.

With great potential for both action and drama, it is a shame that Harmony Gold chose not to spend the needed time to correct the continuity flaws and plug the believability gaps in Minmei's career. Had they done so, this mediocre installment could have been extraordinary.



Love it? Hate it? Buy it.
next page