"Macross II" is a bad sequel. The production concept seems to have been to rip off the
original "Macross," and sell the rehash to "Macross" fans. Fan will recognize all of the
formulaic elements from the original "Macross" in a degenerate duplication, like a bad Xerox
copy. A rash and cocky young hero. Check. Transforming robot space fighters. Check. A
bevy of cow-eyed teenage babes with pouty little mouths. Check. A soapy love triangle, an
alien attack, a plot that revolves around syntho-pop music. Check, check, check.
These elements are cut and stitched together, without transitions nor explanations to
form "Macross II." The plot hinges on the expectation that cliches will rationalize the
storyline from the bones that are given. That Hibiki, Sylvia and Ishtar should each be
points on a love triangle is to be accepted as a matter of course simply because they are
in the same story together, not because there is any logic to back it up. Even worse are the
nonsensical battle treatments. The creators do not allow reason to interfere with plot points as
good guys and bad guys waltz through one another's defenses to perform story devices and dialogue.
In one feeble attempt at character development, Hibiki makes a transition from a reporter willing to
do anything to get a scoop to a reporter concerned with the integrity of a story's content. The
breakneck speed at which he screeches to his new opinion in one 30 second scene causes whiplash. And
his subsequent moralizing comes off not only as jarring, but as laughably simplistic as well.
Only the most forgiving and devoted "Macross" fan will be able to watch "Macross II" without
wincing. Unfamiliarity with the "Macross" universe makes this sequel even worse.
Zentrans + Meltrans = Zentraedi. If these words, along with terms like Valcaron and Micron
and catch phrases like, "Long live culture!" are not in your vocabulary already, "Macross II" will
do nothing to help explain them for you. You will be hopelessly confused whenever they are used.
But this will be the least of the novitiate's issues.
When, in the first ten minutes Earth unveils its keystone defense against alien attack
and it's a singing teenage sexpot, credulity is stretched. This tape does nothing to ease a beginner
into the "Macross" universe. "Macross II" is a sappy, trendy, robotic Frankenstein in a plaid skirt
living in space. Watching it as a first exposure to anime could irreparably damage anyone's
perception of the genre.
The review could end here, but for one other aspect of "Macross II" which was so outstandingly
bad as to demand recognition. The dubbing. Dubbing should be like icing on a cake, adding
sweetness to substance. Luckily, as "Macross II" is insubstantial, there is nothing for the
wooden and amateurish dubbing to ruin. Indeed, it seems fitting that the crappy dialogue is
crappily delivered. Doo-doo cake iced with creme de doo-doo.
Fundamentally, "Macross II" suffers from being horridly underwritten, and so fails everything
it attempts. "Silly" is the kindest word I can think of to describe the cardboard characters.
Yes, the sweet love affairs are there, but forced. Yes, the space battles rage, but absurdly.
"Macross II" was slap dashed together from a brainstormed outline no one bothered to flesh out.