Overall: 4.0
Tugs at the heartstrings more like a spasmadic puppeteer than a tender love story. Though the time traveling structure of the piece promises much, it delivers very little.
Story/Character Development: 5.0
Structurally, the story intrigues. But what ever it gains with the originality of its premise it loses with the sheer inability to mold that into a cohesive, emotionally dynamic story. The characters remain sessile as the story washes over them.
Art/Animation: 7.0
Pale colors and an expert use of stills provide the groundwork for a distinct animation style, but, a lot like the story, none of it really amounts to much.
Translation/Acting: 7.0
Tempered acting on the part of the English cast captures the Japanese essence while the script itself is a type of bland consistent with the initial story.
MPAA Equivalent: PG
Adult scenarios and a peak of flesh. ADV gives it a standardized anime rating of 15+, though the emotional sophistication of the film should demand a bookend rating of 21-.
Format: 5.0
DVD. Responsive navigation gets you through the bare minimum of features. ADV has also included six previews of other titles.
X-Factors
Ph Level 7 Factor: 7.0
The chemistry between Kyosuke and Madoka flatlines before it starts. The only real sparks happen in a dream sequence. The rest of the time Madoka is as artificial as her diet soda.
It Was Better Than Cats Factor: 5.5
Hikaru auditions for a musical very much like "Cats" -- so much so that it could be "Cats." A disappointment since the scenario lends itself to a wealth of joke possibilities about the tastelessness of the modern American musical scene. How about Andrew Lloyd Webber's "For Whom the Bell Tolls," or a Cameron Mackintosh production of "Hiroshima: The Musical?!"