akadot News Articles Columns Reviews Fun Features Forums Retail
Cardcaptors: Volume 1, Tests of Courage
by Lisa Klassen  
cardcaptors1-03.jpg
cardcaptors1-04.jpg
cardcaptors1-05.jpg
review ratings information
ratings
Overall: 7.0
Vehemently criticized for not being "Card Captor Sakura," this amalgamated series offers an abbreviated version of the original, not as bad as "they" say it is, but not as good as "it" says it is.

Story: 6.0
Nelvana hacks and pares all the Japanese cultural references, 'boring' parts, and various other sections of the storyline; and thus hacks and pares this rating down to a six. Bereft of a proper beginning the series flounders across the terrain of the original without capturing the charm.

Character Development: 7.0
Li and Sakura's characters both show growth as they learn to respect one another. Their competitiveness is one of the draws of this series.

Art/Animation: 9.5
Each episode provides an effulgent feast for the eyes rife with interesting details. But, again, the excision of Japanese cultural references dampens the piece's charm.

Acting: 4.5
With the exception of Li and Sakura's family, the voice acting quality is quite poor. An experienced cast would go a long way towards improving this series.

MPAA Equivalent: PG
Though tame, the violence is still there. And "The Cave" can ignite some base fears in small children.


X-Factors

The Amazing, Astounding, (Untested) Battle Outfits Factor: 9.0
Rubberized cloth to protect against lightning, an outfit that's perfect for night flight, Madison is always there with the clothes. Too bad Sakura never gets a chance to try these amazing abilities - she never seems to need what they have to offer. But it's all about looking good, right?

Speaking Loudly to a Foreigner Factor: 1.0
Nelvana's approaches this series as if an American audience couldn't get it, behavior akin to speaking loudly to a non-English speaking as if the sheer volume will make the words easier to understand.



Love it? Hate it? Buy it.
previous pagenext page