Gaping narrative holes and patchwork characters sink this sci-fi effort, but central
to "Blue Seed's" shortcomings is an inability to generate interest in the story. The
world's fate lies in the hands of one girl, but writer Masaharu Amiya makes Momiji too
weak and dependent to make decisions and effect change.
Questions abound as the story opens and Kaede inexplicably decides to sacrifice
herself to understand her destiny. Supposedly Kaede's sacrifice does not adversely
affect the Aragami because she disappears in a beam of light, and therefore, her blood
is not actually spilt. This sacrifice lends Kaede strength, for she takes matters into
her own hands, but throughout the film, Amiya never clarifies why such a sacrifice would
unveil her destiny. Unfortunately, taking one step forward in the universe of strong
character development does not mean that there's any ground on which to step.
Momiji is admittedly naive, but naivete does not have to evince weakness. Amiya
indelibly establishes Momiji as dependent by not giving her the knowledge of her importance
to the world. Furthermore, when Momiji whines about dying an "unkissed virgin," she simply
waxes pathetic. Momiji never takes pride in herself. Regardless of her status as a virgin,
a refreshing stance would involve Momiji accepting herself as she is without making excuses.
Amiya's attempts to make up for Momiji's glaring weakness by introducing an assemblage of
quirky supporting roles, such as Ms. Kome, a tough as nails military recruit. But these
characters hardly develop beyond the stereotypes common to their roles. Ms. Kome is overly
tough, enjoying guns and warfare to the point of ridicule. Granted she's the comic relief,
but over the top and often accident-prone, she is unable to provide any real strength.
Better-developed personal stakes make Kusanagi's story inherently more compelling than
Momiji's. A flashback reveals that Kusanagi was given seven souls from the Aragami family
to make him an Aragami/human hybrid. So, given orders to protect the Kushinada girls,
Kusanagi, who detests working for the Aragami, feels that he can only achieve freedom by
killing the Kushinada girls, thus destroying the Aragami. Kusanagi suffers great personal
conflict which, unfortunately, Amiya nullifies by failing to provide convincing motivation
for the warrior's shift back to protecting Momiji but this time still defying Aragami
enslavement … under which he is forced to live … oh, why bother.
"Blue Seed" tells an enjoyable science fiction story without stretching the imagination
in any way...except when trying to figure out what TI Plasmids are, and why they will kill
a monster.